Antibiotics: To Prescribe or Not Prescribe?
by Marjorie Montemayor-Quellenberg, MA
You are sick and feel miserable. So you go to your doctor for antibiotics to kill what ails you. But instead, your doctor takes a different treatment route that does not include prescribing antibiotics. So why won’t your doctor give you antibiotics? Sometimes drugs can be more harmful than helpful.
When Medicine Meets Resistance
Many things can make you sick, such as bacteria, viruses, fungi, or other microorganisms. The most commonly prescribed antibiotics only work against bacteria. Therefore, they may not be helpful if a virus or other microorganism causes your condition. When prescribed and taken correctly, antibiotics can be very effective. They can shorten the time you are sick and keep the disease from spreading to others.
Perhaps because they are so effective, doctors may have a tendency to prescribe them too often. Because of this overuse, over time some bacteria adapt ways to resist antibiotics, making these medications less effective or unable to work at all.
Antibiotic resistance is harmful because as more antibiotics are introduced into our environment, by either over-prescribing or entering our food chain through their use in the dairy, poultry, and livestock industries, more strains of bacteria have the potential to become resistant. Some that are already resistant to antibiotics are
Some bacteria may be resistant to only one antibiotic, while others are resistant to a range of antibiotics. These multidrug-resistant bacteria create a challenge for doctors. Patients with conditions caused by these types of bacteria not only endure longer hospital stays, but they may have to be put on many drugs in hopes that one of the medications or the combination of medications will work. Often these drugs can be toxic and ineffective. Patients infected with antibiotic-resistant bacteria are more likely to die from their illnesses.
To Prescribe or to Not Prescribe? TOP
So when is an antibiotic right for you? That is for your doctor to decide. In cases when your doctor decides against antibiotics, it is most likely because a virus causes your condition or it will go away without medication.
A cold and the flu are caused by viruses. Antibiotics are not useful in treating these conditions or their symptoms. In certain circumstances, a bacterial infection can occur along with a cold and flu. In these situations, antibiotics may be prescribed.
Viruses also cause many runny noses, congested sinuses, coughs, and sore throats. However, these can also be caused by bacterial infections. For example, if your sore throat is caused by bacteria, as in strep throat, your doctor will prescribe antibiotics.
Viruses or bacteria can cause middle ear infections. Your doctor will determine if antibiotic treatment is needed.
UTIs are often caused by bacteria and are usually treated with antibiotics.
You may also be prescribed antibiotics if bacteria are known to cause your illness or the cause is unknown and the doctor determines it is better to treat with antibiotics than not.
If Given Antibiotics… TOP
If your doctor does decide to prescribe antibiotics, it is important that you follow all dosing instructions carefully and completely. This goes for any medications your doctor may prescribe.
Although generally safe, if you are taking antibiotics there are some things you should know:
It is important to tell your doctor if you are pregnant, think you may be pregnant, or are nursing. Certain antibiotics may be harmful to your baby.
Now that you are aware of why your doctor may or may not give you antibiotics, it is important that you continue to have open discussions with her about your treatment options. Ask questions. Share any information regarding your medical history. Discuss side effects that concern you. And if you do not understand something, speak up. Having a two-way discussion will help your doctor plan the best treatment approach for you.
Alliance for the Prudent Use of Antibiotics
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Pharmacy and You American Pharmacists Association
Canadian Medical Association
About antimicrobial resistance: a brief overview. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention website. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/drugresistance/about.html. Updated July 2, 2012. Accessed March 14, 2013.
Understanding Antimicrobial Resistance. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases website. Available at: http://www.niaid.n.... Updated April 3, 2012. Accessed March 14, 2013.
What is Antibiotic Resistance and Why is it a problem? Alliance for the Prudent Use of Antibiotics website. Available at: http://www.tufts.edu/med/apua/about_issue/antibiotic_res.shtml. Accessed March 14, 2013.
Last reviewed March 2013 by Brian Randall, MD
Last Updated: 3/14/2013